Skip to content

Traditional Egg Custard Tart with Nutmeg

Egg custard tart. What a delicious dessert. We love this simple recipe in our house. Always a family favourite. Easy to make, and the kids can help! Yum!! | theyumyumclub.com
Prep 25 mins
Cook 1 hr 15 mins
Total 1 hr 40 mins
Serves 8 servings
Calories 491 kcal
Updated:

What can be yummier than a traditional egg custard tart with nutmeg? As kids we all had them as little, individual tarts, packed in our lunch boxes, usually next to the soggy cheese sandwich. For me, the egg custard was always left until last. The best of the best. Nothing could beat it. Or could there be something…

As a child those little egg custard tarts were the best. But what if, as an adult, we could make a bigger one? A whole, family size tart, with more egg custard to pastry? “Can there be such a heavenly dessert?” “Is it possible?” I hear you all cry.

Well my fellow dessert disciples, behold the full-size traditional egg custard tart with nutmeg. Yum!

I know what you’re all thinking. You’re thinking old Stevie has been using his Photoshop skills again and just enlarging a little egg custard tart. This cannot be real.

Well, my friends, it is a whole tart. And what’s more, you can have one too. Yes, this eggcellent, eggciting and eggxotic (sorry, I couldn’t help myself) egg custard tart is well within your grasp.

C’mon, I’ll show you how.

1. Gather all of the ingredients together

You should know me by now. I always pull all of the ingredients together first. It’s far less stressful all round.

For this egg custard tart recipe, you will basically need to make the pastry base and then the egg custard filling. I therefore set aside two separate groups of ingredients before I started to cook.

Flour, butter, icing sugar, egg yolks, cream, milk, lemon and nutmeg on a counter
Everything for the pastry and the custard, ready before you start.
Pastry ingredients and egg custard ingredients set out on a counter
Ingredients for the egg custard filling.

2. Make the pastry

The simple way of making the pastry is to put the flour, butter, icing sugar, and egg yolk in a blender and, using the pulse function, mix all the ingredients together until they start to bind and form a pastry.

If you don’t have a blender, use the traditional method instead.

For this, put the flour and icing sugar in a bowl and mix together. Then add the butter and simply squash these 3 ingredients together over and over again. Keep rubbing the mixture lightly through your hands until you have a breadcrumb-like texture.

Flour, icing sugar and butter rubbed together into crumbs
Rub the flour, icing sugar and butter together to form a crumb.

Next, add the egg.

Egg yolk added to the crumb mixture in a bowl
Add the egg.

Finally, mix this all together and knead until a pastry ball is formed. This should only take a minute or so.

3. Form the egg custard tart base

You now need to form the base and blind bake it. Blind baking is a method used in baking when the filling of the pie will take a shorter time to bake than the pastry used for the pie. It’s commonly used for desserts with pastry bases, and for savoury dishes like quiche.

The first thing to do is roll the pastry out so that it will fit a 22 cm cake tin. The best type of tin to use for an egg custard tart is a fluted cake tin with a removable base. Fill the tin and push the pastry into the tin flutes and break off any excess pastry so you end with a neat base. Then dock the pastry with a fork by pricking holes in the base.

Pastry pressed into a fluted tin and docked with a fork
Dock the pastry with a fork.

Before baking line the base with tin foil and add either baking beads or any dried pulses to weigh the foil down and stop the pastry from moving.

Pastry case lined with foil and baking beads
Pastry case ready for blind baking.

Now bake the base by placing in a pre-heated oven at 200C / 180C Fan for 15 minutes. After this remove the foil and weights and bake for a further 5-10 minutes until the pastry is golden.

Golden blind-baked pastry case in a fluted tin
The baked pastry case, golden and ready for filling.

It’s now time to make the filling but before you start, turn the oven down to 140C / 120C Fan.

4. Make the egg custard filling

For the filling, add the cream, milk, and lemon zest to a small saucepan. Next, add a small drop of vanilla essence and a pinch of nutmeg. Finally, place this on a low heat, bring it to the boil and then set aside.

Whilst the milk and cream mixture is heating up take the egg yolks and whisk in the sugar until the mixture goes a pale orange colour.

Egg yolks and sugar whisked until pale orange in a bowl
Whisk until pale orange.

Now, whilst continually whisking, add the cream and milk mixture slowly to the egg and sugar mixture. Remember to keep whisking.

Warm cream and milk being whisked into the egg mixture
Keep whisking as you pour.

Finally, pass this custard through a fine sieve to remove any lumps and stand aside for 5 minutes or so. Then spoon off any froth from the top of the egg custard so you are left with liquid only.

Smooth egg custard being poured into a baked pastry case in a fluted tin
Pour the strained custard into the warm pastry case.

5. Finish off the traditional egg custard tart with nutmeg

Once the base is cooked and the oven has got down to 140C / 120C Fan carefully pour the egg custard into the base and sprinkle some nutmeg over the top. Bake the egg custard tart for 40 minutes or until the egg custard has set and has just the slightest wobble in the center when you jiggle it.

Now, remove from the oven and set aside for 30 minutes. Finally, remove from the tin and let cool properly in the fridge.

There you have it. A wonderful family size egg custard tart. Yum Yum! Once cooled, keep it in the fridge. The Food Standards Agency advises cooling cooked food and putting it in the fridge within one to two hours, and eating leftovers within two days (or freezing them), so cut and serve it soon after it has chilled.

Nutmeg-dusted egg custard tart with one slice served on a side plate
The finished tart, sliced and ready to serve.

OK, my fine food friends! That’s it for now. I do hope you enjoyed the recipe and give it a go yourselves. I’d love to hear how you get on. Leave me a comment or question if you like. The recipe card is just below.

As always, many thanks for reading, and until next time… Steve.

Recipe card

The Yum Yum Club · Kitchen Tested Recipe

Egg Custard Tart

A blind-baked pastry case filled with a cream, milk and egg yolk custard flavoured with lemon zest and nutmeg, baked until set.

Prep: 25 mins · Cook: 1 hr 15 mins · Total: 1 hr 40 mins

Save Pin
4 from 1 vote

Ingredients

8 servings

For the pastry

For the egg custard

Nutrition Facts

Per Serving: 1 serving

Calories 491
Total Fat 25.5g
Carbohydrates 49.7g
Protein 13.3g

Nutrition values are estimates calculated per serving from the ingredient list.

Instructions

  1. 1

    Firstly get all the ingredients together. The order if making will be firstly the pastry and then the egg custard.

    Egg custard tart. What a delicious dessert. We love this simple recipe in our house. Always a family favourite. Easy to make, and the kids can help! Yum!! | theyumyumclub.com
  2. 2

    For the pastry put the flour, icing sugar, butter and egg yolk in a blender. Then, on a pulse setting, mix until a pastry ball is formed. Do not over mix.

  3. 3

    Now, roll the pastry out so it will fit a 20-25 cm fluted pie tin. Press the pastry into the flutes and dock with a fork.

    Egg custard tart. What a delicious dessert. We love this simple recipe in our house. Always a family favourite. Easy to make, and the kids can help! Yum!! | theyumyumclub.com
  4. 4

    Now cover the base with kitchen foil and weigh down with baking beads or pulses ready for blind baking.

    Egg custard tart. What a delicious dessert. We love this simple recipe in our house. Always a family favourite. Easy to make, and the kids can help! Yum!! | theyumyumclub.com
  5. 5

    Bake for 15 minutes in a pre-heated oven at 200C / 180C Fan. The remove the foil and weight and bake for a further 5-10 minutes until golden brown.

    Egg custard tart. What a delicious dessert. We love this simple recipe in our house. Always a family favourite. Easy to make, and the kids can help! Yum!! | theyumyumclub.com
  6. 6

    For the filling take the cream, milk and lemon zest and add to a small saucepan. Next, add a drop of vanilla essence and a pinch of nutmeg. Bring to the boil and set aside. 

  7. 7

    Now, beat the egg yolks and sugar until they turn a pale orange color.

    Egg custard tart. What a delicious dessert. We love this simple recipe in our house. Always a family favourite. Easy to make, and the kids can help! Yum!! | theyumyumclub.com
  8. 8

    Next, pour the milk and cream mixture slowly into the egg and sugar mix whisking throughout.

    Egg custard tart. What a delicious dessert. We love this simple recipe in our house. Always a family favourite. Easy to make, and the kids can help! Yum!! | theyumyumclub.com
  9. 9

    Now sieve this mixture to remove the lemon zest and remove any froth from the top.

  10. 10

    Finally, pour the mixture into the pastry case and sprinkle some nutmeg over the top. Bake in a pre-heated oven at 140C / 120C Fan for 40 minutes or until the egg custard has set.

    Egg custard tart. What a delicious dessert. We love this simple recipe in our house. Always a family favourite. Easy to make, and the kids can help! Yum!! | theyumyumclub.com
  11. 11

    Remove from the oven and let cool.

    Egg custard tart. What a delicious dessert. We love this simple recipe in our house. Always a family favourite. Easy to make, and the kids can help! Yum!! | theyumyumclub.com
  12. 12

    And there you are. A wonderful family sized egg custard tart! Yum!!

    Egg custard tart. What a delicious dessert. We love this simple recipe in our house. Always a family favourite. Easy to make, and the kids can help! Yum!! | theyumyumclub.com

Kitchen Notes & Tips

Nutrition values are an estimate calculated from the ingredient list, not a lab analysis.

Steve Deacon

Steve Deacon

Founder & Writer

Hi, I'm Steve, founder of The Yum Yum Club. After years in the corporate rat race traveling the world, my wife Jen and I settled back in the UK to follow our true passion: great food and wine. Having worked in restaurant kitchens in my youth, I share honest home-cooked recipes, kitchen timing tips, and culinary discoveries.

View all posts by Steve Deacon →

4 comments

  1. Looks nice never tried one.
    The other day I tried to poach an egg in a ramaken it certainly didn’t look as good as yours
    What did I do wrong

    1. Hi Kay, try the custard tart. It’s really easy. Re the poached eggs, makes sure you lower the ramekins in slowly so as not to disturb the egg. That should work. Let me know. If still a problem I’ll come round and show you 😉